Subscribe to Waco Trib XML RSS Feed E-Newsletter WacoTrib on your PDA
Welcome, Bob   |  Update Profile  |  Log Out
Neighbor Plus| State | Nation | Photos/Multimedia | World | Weather | Archives

Faculty 'massacre' blamed on Baylor's confusing tenure criteria

Thursday, April 03, 2008

By Tim Woods

Tribune-Herald staff writer

When the 12 faculty candidates recently denied tenure by Baylor University requested an explanation, they got it: a form letter telling them their research fell short.

Three of those candidates are celebrated by the school in posters and display cases across campus for their research. They and others affected by the tenure “massacre,” as one Baylor professor calls it, aren’t the only ones asking questions about the exact standards to earn tenure at the university.

“Given your reduced teaching responsibilities, you have not conclusively demonstrated, in the area of research, that tenure should be awarded by Baylor University,” Baylor Provost Randall O’Brien wrote in the form letter.

One of the 12, information systems professor Robin Wakefield, is named as one of the “Hankamer Professors Making a Name in Research” for her work in e-commerce research. Wakefield’s and a few other professors’ research is touted in a sealed case on the first floor of the Hankamer School of Business at Baylor.

Two others — electrical and computer engineering professor Russ Duren and mechanical engineering professor Carolyn Skurla — are featured in posters on the second floor of Pat Neff Hall, outside the office of Baylor Vice Provost for Research Truell Hyde. The posters read, “Baylor Research: Making a difference” and include the professors’ names and pictures.

Another of the denied professors, Randall Jean, is working to develop a blood glucose sensor that would eliminate painful finger-prick blood tests for diabetics. Colleague Robert Marks, a tenured engineering professor who has worked with Jean on the project, says “the impact (of Jean’s work) will be extraordinary.”

At the heart of the matter: allegations of shifting standards and fuzzy criteria for tenure. Baylor professors — tenured and not — and alumni are seeking answers to this and several other issues related to the tenure process.

However, O’Brien, after speaking to the Tribune-Herald about the matter in March, is now referring questions to the marketing and communications office. Baylor regents chairman Harold Cunningham also was unavailable for comment on the mounting tenure controversy.

This spring, 12 of 30 candidates at Baylor were denied tenure. At 40 percent, the denial rate under President John Lilley was a sharp increase from recent years, according to Faculty Senate Chairman Matt Cordon, a law school professor.

Marks called the tenure denials a “massacre” and said “the administration’s decisions about this year’s tenure swept over Baylor like a tsunami. It was totally unexpected and had an entirely significant body count.”

Several of the 12 — referred to as the “Denied Dozen” on popular Baylor chat Web site — say their denials were confounding and the result of tenure guidelines being changed after their tenure notebooks were submitted.

“What President Lilley has done in the last month is to say: ‘I’m holding you to a different standard. I’m not telling you what that standard is, and I’m not giving you prior notice of what it’s going to be,’ ” Baylor biology professor Rene Massengale said in an earlier interview after learning of her denial.

Massengale and several others denied tenure would not comment for this article, as they have begun their appeal process.

In some respects, the appeals process is more of a reconsideration than anything else, yet another point of frustration for faculty candidates trying to win tenure. The appeal is made to the president and the provost who denied tenure in the first place, Cordon said.

Regarding the posters and displays across campus touting some of the professors’ research accomplishments, Baylor spokeswoman Lori Fogleman said they were produced by the school’s marketing and communications office. She noted that her department is separate from the tenure decision-makers.

“It’s our job to find the great stories and what professors are working on . . . and make sure that other people know about those,” Fogleman said.

Fogleman wouldn’t discuss whether a form letter is an appropriate response to a faculty candidate’s request for the reason tenure was denied.

“How we communicate personnel matters is covered by privacy law,” she said. “It’s not only policy at Baylor but it’s law as well, that employees have a right to privacy and we don’t intend to violate that by discussing privacy matters.”

Cordon, the Faculty Senate chairman, said he has a regularly scheduled meeting Friday with O’Brien in which he plans to ask for clarification of how faculty should approach the administration to determine what the tenure criteria are and what they should expect in the process. He said he has been approached by a number of faculty asking questions for which they haven’t gotten answers from the Baylor administration.

Fogleman wouldn’t say whether O’Brien will address such questions from Cordon at the meeting, citing the confidential nature of the meetings.

The tenure controversy is beginning to reach beyond the campus.

Baylor Alumni Association executive vice president Jeff Kilgore said, “The alumni are always concerned with the state of affairs of the university, especially when it comes to academics, and this issue has certainly created a lot of attention and raised a lot of concern among the alumni, chiefly because it has raised a lot of concern among the faculty.”

He added, “The temperature of the faculty is at the heart of it and (the BAA) certainly supports our faculty.”

Kilgore said he’s heard from a number of alumni on the issue.

“What I understand from my academic colleagues is that this is something that’s abnormal, which is causing a lot of calls from alumni asking, ‘Is it a good thing or a bad thing?’ ” Kilgore said.


What does tenure mean?

Tenure, for a college or university professor, means job security and is intended to ensure academic freedom.

It is awarded following sufficient showing in areas of research, teaching and publication— usually over a term of five to seven years.

Having tenure protects teachers when they openly speak out on authority, but also is designed to promote new and original ideas in a free-thinking atmosphere. Tenure also is sometimes credited with creating an atmosphere of loyalty, as professors work to improve the school where they will work their entire career.

Criticisms of the tenure system include allowing professors to become lazy, complacent and irrelevant, having been granted so much job security.

A snapshot of the research of a few of the 12 professors denied tenure by Baylor:

Randall Jean, engineering: Developing a prick-free blood glucose sensor that would save diabetics the painful process of drawing blood several times a day. Jean was tenured at Texas A&M University in 1984 and has been at Baylor since 2003.

What others are saying: “Denial of tenure for Dr. Jean will delay the blood sugar research for years, or derail it entirely,” said Baylor colleague Robert Marks.

Lori Baker, anthropology: Secured contracts with Mexican government to analyze bone samples from cadavers in Arizona desert and test blood samples of possible relatives at home. She has helped identify over 70 people and return their remains to their families in Mexico and Central America.

What others are saying: “In terms of making a lasting impact, I don’t know of anybody who’s doing more than she is right now, in terms of identifying people outside this country. She’s one of the top anthropology researchers in DNA in this country,” said Steve Symes, tenured professor at Mercyhurst College in Pennsylvania, recently awarded lifetime achievement award from the Forensic Anthropology Association.

Rene Massengale, biology: Current work focuses on the role of pathogens in affecting water quality and environmental contamination, as well as researching rapid detection of biological agents in drinking water. She has brought in more than $1 million in grant money since coming to Baylor in 2001.

What others are saying: “She is, in some ways, laying the foundation for people who will move the field ahead,” said Robert McLean, tenured biology professor at Texas State University. “She’s doing really good, solid work, looking at more than just numbers of (publications) or grant dollars coming in. It’s my perception that at high-powered places it’s about (grant) money, papers and no red flags for teaching. I think Baylor is a lot more than that, hence my disappointment (in learning of Massengale’s tenure denial).”

Russ Duren, engineering: Works on reconfigurable computing, essentially chips that can be programmed to be a computer. Has done a lot of work on reconfigurable computing for the U.S. government and has updated software for the F-18 Hornet, a military fighter jet.

What others are saying: “The value is in flexibility of computing,” Baylor colleague Marks said. “Clearly it’s on state-of-the-art government vessels. (Duren) has an international reputation in this and was actually called before the National Academies to talk about his work and give his thoughts on what the future of reconfigurable computing will be.”


By Nimininsky Hater

Apr 4, 2008 11:15 AM | Link to this

Why does Nimoninsky get to reveal names of faculty and alumni but hide behind the cloak of anonymity? Frank Beckwith is Nimoninsky and he is a coward.

By Alumni

Apr 4, 2008 8:46 AM | Link to this

I've personally known 4-5 who have been denied during the past 6 years- hmmm...........not good!

By anonymous

Apr 4, 2008 4:51 AM | Link to this

Responding to Rosie's comment - One of the reasons this has people so angry is that, in at least 9 of the 12 cases the departments, the tenure board, and the provost voted to grant tenure only to have Lilly himself deny it.

By get a clue

Apr 3, 2008 11:45 PM | Link to this

If you think including a quote from that "fan" website in your story somehow gave it more credibility, you achieved exactly the opposite.

By Rosie

Apr 3, 2008 10:59 PM | Link to this

I don't think that many people honestly understand the process that goes on to become tenured. Thinking that the president sits there and slashed the names off is not even true. It all begins with the department and they vote and decide if you should even be considered. Just because you wrote many papers or recieved a grant or developed anything does not insure you will be voted to be tenured. Your actions, teaching skills, and ability to interact with others in your department are taking in consideration. You may have your very own department all vote for you not to recieve tenure. And even sometimes they may vote your way, but someone else has decided that you don't deserve it futher along in the process. When it finally reaches the President if he sees that everyone else voted for you not to recieve tenure thant you most like not get it.

By Nancy

Apr 3, 2008 5:22 PM | Link to this

To Huligan-
Are you Lilley's mom or something? Defending him when clearly he has made bad decisions? If you read this article, which is truth, no one in their right mind can deduce that Lilley was right in these decisions (except an irrational mother).
I'm not even sure I want to attend Baylor if our administration, or rather our president, clearly can not make good decisions.
You spelled Hooligan wrong anyway.

By Chris

Apr 3, 2008 4:43 PM | Link to this

Baylor is constantly talking about the school being a "Christian University." However, it worships at the altar of its own narcistic ego. Vision 2012 has ruined Baylor beyond repair. Baylor does not need to turn into yet another research institution that counts teaching as being second rate.

Also, let's face it: Baylor is and always will be extremely political. Baylor can't help it. It's a Baptist institution.

All of the professors denied tenure should be given it immediately. Stop the 2012 grandstanding and start teaching!!!

By Chris

Apr 3, 2008 4:42 PM | Link to this

Baylor is constantly talking about the school being a "Christian University." However, it worships at the altar of its own narcistic ego. Vision 2012 has ruined Baylor beyond repair. Baylor does not need to turn into yet another research institution that counts teaching as being second rate.

Also, let's face it: Baylor is and always will be extremely political. Baylor can't help it. It's a Baptist institution.

All of the professors denied tenure should be given it immediately. Stop the 2012 grandstanding and start teaching!!!

By Christian Baylor Fella

Apr 3, 2008 2:15 PM | Link to this

Listen up Bear Fans, lets stop the madness. This can all be settled over a few drinks at Scruffy Murphys. The restrooms are now clearly marked in case you get crosseyed.

If we are lucky maybe some coaches will show up and give us a preview of the fightin' bears 08 team.


Apr 3, 2008 12:32 PM | Link to this

Now I know why my family doesn't support Baylor University. Seems to me they don't have confidence in their own faculty.

[1 2] next

Commenting is open from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. M-F, except on Tuesday when it's open until 9 p.m.

Post a comment

Remember me?

You may use the following formatting:
Bold: **this text will be bolded** = this text will be bolded
Italic: *this text will be italic* = this text will be italic
Link: [text to be linked]( = text to be linked

There will be a delay of up to 5 minutes before your comment appears.

*HTML not allowed in comments. Your e-mail address is required.

ADMINISTRATIVE & SALESPerformance, Excellence ......(more)
POST (Add job to the account) Payment ......(more)
DRIVERSCompany Sponsored ......(more)
EDUCATIONMcLennan Community College1400 College ......(more)
DRIVER/ PATIENT SERVICE TECHNICIAN needed. FT w/ benefits. Please call ABB...(more)
GENERAL OFFICE ASSISTANTSeeking enthusiastic ......(more)
NIGHTCLUB - Needed immediately Dancers & Waitresses. Call 214-3452...(more)
TRUCK DRIVER w/CDL Steel Fabricator ......(more)
ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANTProfessional firm ......(more)
Waco Tribune-Herald Top Cars
Chevrolet Avalanche 1500 2004. 5.3, 8 Cyl., Automatic, Fuel Injected, PEWTE......(more)
2007 FUSION 4DR, 2.3L I4, WHITE, 5SPD, $17995...(more)
Nissan Quest 2006. 3.5, 6 Cyl., Automatic, Fuel Injected, RED, Power Window......(more)
Ford Focus ZX4 2005. 2.0, 4 Cyl., Automatic, Fuel Injected, BLUE, Power Win......(more)
Chevrolet Tahoe 2004. 5.3, 8 Cyl., Automatic, Fuel Injected, BLUE, Power Wi......(more)
Chevrolet TrailBlazer 2007. 4.2, 6 Cyl., Automatic, Fuel Injected, MAROON, ......(more)
Chevrolet 2500 Silverado 2004. 6.6, 8 Cyl., Automatic, Turbo Diesel, MAROON......(more)
Cadillac SRX 2007. 3.6, 6 Cyl., Automatic, Fuel Injected, SILVER, Power Win......(more)
Chevrolet Suburban 1500 2005. 5.3, 8 Cyl., Automatic, Fuel Injected, GRAY, ......(more)
Ford Edge SEL 2007. 3.5, 6 Cyl., Automatic, Fuel Injected, BLACK, Power Win......(more)
-View All Top Cars-
-Place an Ad-

Wacotrib News | Wacotrib Weather | Sports | Living | Business News | Wacotrib Schools | Opinions | Baylor Football
Wacotrib Cars | Wacotrib Real Estate | Wacotrib Jobs | Classifieds | Sitemap

Copyright 2008 Waco Tribune-Herald. All rights reserved. - The Waco Tribune-Herald - Our Partners

By using this service, you accept the terms of our visitor agreement and privacy policy.
Registered site users, you may edit your profile.
Having trouble? Visit our help & FAQ.