You are not logged in...
chron.comNews, search and shopping from the Houston Chronicle
Today's Weather
Pt. Sunny Partly Cloudy
86° 94° 76°
Chronicle logo

July 24, 2008, 4:10PM
Citing lost confidence, Baylor regents fire president

Yahoo! Buzz

Baylor University's board of regents fired the Baptist school's president on Thursday, saying they had lost confidence in his ability to "unite various Baylor constituencies."

John M. Lilley, on the job less than three years, rejected an offer to serve out his five-year contract as regents searched for a replacement.

Lilley's relatively brief tenure was marked by disputes over tenure and even over the university's logo. But how best to achieve Baylor's goal of becoming a major research university without sacrificing its strong Christian character appears to have been an issue, as well.

Board Chairman Howard K. Batson, speaking to reporters in a conference call, declined to say exactly why regents replaced Lilley, who was hired in November 2005. Lilley's time in office coincided with record fund-raising, higher SAT scores for incoming students and a jump in the school's ranking on a list compiled by U.S. News and World Report, Batson acknowledged.

Still, he said, "the reality is, the board lost confidence in John's ability to unite various Baylor constituencies.

"This is a time of transition as Baylor tries to become a top-tier university ... with a new emphasis on research in a setting that embraces both faith and learning. That is a time of change, and change is always hard."

Regent Harold Cunningham will serve as acting president until an interim president can be found.

Batson said regents offered to let Lilley to remain in office while they conducted a national search for his replacement. Lilley declined.

In an e-mail to the Baptist Standard, he appeared defiant. "I deeply regret the action of the board, and I do not believe that it reflects the best interests of Baylor University," he wrote.

A key issue has been Baylor's Vision 2012, an ambitious plan that calls for the school, the world's largest Baptist university, to marry strong Biblical principles with cutting-edge research.

Batson said that Lilley's faith was never an issue — Lilley is Baptist, but had been active in the Presbyterian church before he was hired for the top spot at Baylor — but noted that the next president will be Baptist.

Jeff Reeter, managing partner at Texas Financial Group in Houston and former chairman of the Baylor Development Council, said the concern is not that Lilley has taken Baylor in a more secular direction, but that the school is ready for an even "bolder" vision.

"Baylor has a unique position in our world that many in academia thinks is a difficult position," he said, noting the often-mentioned conflict between Biblical beliefs, including creationism or intelligent design, and science. "We feel that is part of our calling. I think Baylor believes the two things cannot only coexist, but they can powerfully coexist."

Readers are solely responsible for the content of the comments they post here. Comments are subject to the site's terms and conditions of use and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or approval of the Houston Chronicle. Readers whose comments violate the terms of use may have their comments removed or all of their content blocked from viewing by other users without notification.
Most recommended comments
User Image
I don't have a dog in this fight, but as a PhD, I wouldn't want to teach or conduct research at Baylor if I knew that any findings I discovered had to be consonant with Biblical teachings. I am a Christian, but when conducting research, it is inappropriate to carry a bias into the conduct of that research. This will always be a barrier for Baylor if it hopes to attract "top tier" scientist.

I don't know the details of firing of Dr. Lilley, but it sounds like he was doing a great job but was unable to mollify the religious and political views of the Board of Regents. Another university with less polemical views will land him soon and he will do great things there. I'm sorry for Baylor, because other than this Achilles heel, I think it is a great school.
7/24/2008 4:37:04 PM
User Image
rgvguy wrote:
Baylor. The most overpriced, overrated school in America. And it's a religious University. Why shell out all that money when you could go to UT and go to church on Sundays?
7/24/2008 4:46:55 PM
User Image
OwenTurner wrote:
As Baylor grad, I say they do the state, country and world a favor and shut the place down. It did a poor job preparing me for life outside the "Bubble" and I'm tired of people assuming I'm a Bible-thumping nut job because I went to school there. More accurately, my parents forced me to go there -- just like every thinking person that ever enrolled in that place.
7/24/2008 5:10:03 PM
User Image
RogerTxas wrote:
This guy was fired for wanting to allow research into areas which cannot be explained except by what the Bible says??? Has the Baptist church become so narrow that they are unwilling to admit other possibilities? Sounds to me like the Regents ought to go and Lilley should stay!
7/24/2008 4:36:28 PM
User Image
TX1836 wrote:
I understand it's a Bible university, but seriously.....
The book has no substantive proof and so they might as well hold Green Eggs and Ham as their standard. Religion has been the biggest conspiracy in history. Produce your god, otherwise it doesn't exist.
7/24/2008 4:42:18 PM

IN Chronicle